Editing Axe

Jump to navigation Jump to search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 33: Line 33:
 
| skill 1 = Crafting
 
| skill 1 = Crafting
 
| skill 1 level = 3
 
| skill 1 level = 3
−
| has quality = True
 
 
}}
 
}}
 
The '''Axe''' is a [[Weapons#Melee Weapons|melee weapon]] added by the [[Royalty DLC]] that primarily deals sharp damage.
 
The '''Axe''' is a [[Weapons#Melee Weapons|melee weapon]] added by the [[Royalty DLC]] that primarily deals sharp damage.
  
−
'''Note:''' Although classified by the [[Ideoligion]] Weapon Preferences{{IdeologyIcon}} as a 'Melee Blunt' weapon along with weapons that predominantly deal blunt damage, its primary attack deal sharp damage. It is unknown if this categorization is a bug or intended behavior.
+
'''Note:''' Although classified by the [[Ideoligion]] Weapon Preferences{{IdeologyIcon}} as a 'Melee Blunt' weapon along with weapons that predominately deal blunt damage, its primary attack deal sharp damage. It is unknown if this categorization is a bug or intended behavior.
  
 
== Acquisition ==
 
== Acquisition ==
Line 45: Line 44:
  
 
== Analysis ==
 
== Analysis ==
−
The axe is roughly equal to the [[gladius]] - they both have the same material cost, and same research cost. However, axes are strictly inferior than a [[knife]] of the same quality and material.
+
{{stub|section=1|reason=Questions regarding to Cut vs Stab damage}}
 +
The axe is roughly equal to the [[gladius]] and [[mace]] - all 3 weapons have the same material cost, crafting skill, and research requirements. Maces take {{ticks|1000}} less work, and gladii take {{ticks|5000}} more work. Reducing work will slightly reduce the [[Market Value]] of weapons.
  
−
This oddity comes from the [[melee verb selection]] system, introduced in 1.1. Each weapon has multiple attacks, or ''verbs'', with some better than others. The game's infobox incorrectly calculates the likelihood of each attack (it uses RimWorld 1.0 values). For example, the knife is assumed to use "Bad" attacks more often than it does in practice. With this in mind, knives have a "true" {{DPS}} of 7.23, rather than the gladius' 7.13 or axe's 6.75.  
+
===Comparison to gladius===
 +
<!-- Cut v Stab sources: https://steamcommunity.com/app/294100/discussions/0/3042732243097084212 & https://steamcommunity.com/app/294100/discussions/0/3111394035968026504 . Also yes x1.4 cleaving multiplier exists, test it yourself with a plasteel knife -->
 +
In raw stats: the gladius has {{+|{{%|(7.13 / 6.75) - 1 round 3}} }} to raw {{DPS}} and very slightly more {{AP}}, after accounting for melee verb selection. This assumes same material and [[quality]]. Either weapon of a superior quality or material will be a better overall weapon.
  
−
In addition, knives are just as likely as axes to do ''Cut'' damage, so there is no advantage of the axe's damage type. The axe has 4% more {{AP}}, however, this is unlikely to matter for any reasonable enemy you'll encounter. If armor was that much of a concern, then you would use a [[mace]] instead.
+
However, the main difference between the two weapons come from their damage types. For their "Best" attack, the axe can only use ''[[Damage Type#Cut|Cut]]'' damage (75%). Meanwhile, the gladius has an equal chance to either ''Cut'' or ''[[Damage Type#Stab|Stab]]'' (37.5% for each). Therefore, the axe is more likely to Cut. Cut damage has multiple interlocking mechanics that make comparison complex:
 +
* Cut damage has a large chance to ''cleave''. When an attack cleaves, it is spread throughout body parts, but deals x1.4 damage in total. Cut damage causes more [[pain]], but is less likely to destroy an individual body parts.
 +
* ''If'' cut reduces a body part's damage to 0 HP, it is much more likely to destroy it. To always destroy the body part, a cut would only need 110% of a part's remaining HP. A stab would need to do 170% damage. But, as stabs are always concentrated on one body part, stabs are better at destroying large body parts.
 +
* Stab damage is more likely to hit the internal organs. In addition, stab damage receives no penalty for attacking the internals. This results in a higher one-shot chance.
 +
The most important factor, by far, is the cleave mechanic.
  
−
A potential use is for [[ideoligion]]{{IdeologyIcon}} with the Melee Blunt set as Noble weapons, providing a sharp-type weapon option that grants mood buffs instead of penalties.  
+
<!--The following equation is solving 1.4x + 1(1-x) = 1.056 for x-->
 +
If at least {{%| ((7.13 / 6.75) - 1) <!--Gladius' higher DPS, conv. to %--> / (0.4) <!-- Extra % dmg from cleave --> / 0.5 <!--For the "best" melee attack, gladius 50% as likely to cut. "Mid" attacks are exactly equal.--> round 3}} of ''all'' cut attacks cleave, then the axe will be superior in raw DPS.{{Check Tag|Verify Cleave %|Comparison changes based the % chance}} Axes are definitely better against small [[animal]]s, as the axe is more likely to destroy multiple low-HP body parts. Gladii are most likely better against [[mechanoid]]s - mechs don't feel [[pain]], increasing the value of limb destruction. The weapon that deals more average DPS will be better against humanoids of any armor. Note that this is theoretical and no explicit testing has been conducted.
  
−
{{Weapon Stats Table}}
+
===Comparison to maces===
 +
Maces are blunt weapons.  Maces have +{{%|(7.01 / 6.75) - 1 round 3}} raw DPS, but due to cleaving described above, the axe ends up being superior in average DPS. But like with the gladius comparison, there are big differences with their damage types.
 +
 
 +
* "Armored" enemies tend to have much less Blunt armor than Sharp armor. For example, a set of [[recon armor]] has 96% Sharp but only 40% Blunt armor. Therefore, blunt weapons are better against armored enemies.
 +
* Blunt weapons have a superior form of damage propagation. Instead of being spread equally between parts like ''Cut'' damage, blunt damage attacks a single part - and only if the part would be destroyed, then overkill damage spreads to component parts. In addition, the mace swings slower but hits stronger. This results in maces being more likely than both the gladius and the axe in destroying large body parts.
 +
* If a blunt attack hits the torso or head, then the target will be stunned for a short time. 
 +
 
 +
With [[steel]] weapons, or at lower qualities, the mace would be better against [[plate armor]]-level armor, and axes better against unarmored targets. However, higher quality [[uranium]] maces is likely better than high quality [[plasteel]] axes against any sort of human or human-sized enemy. A good uranium mace can one-shot the head or limbs.
 +
 
 +
===Comparison to other weapons===
 +
Compared to more complex melee weapons, an axe is superior in raw DPS to a [[longsword]] at least 2 quality levels below. For instance, a legendary steel axe is better than an excellent steel longsword. [[Warhammer]]s have very slightly more DPS than the axe (less than the mace), but are blunt and swing even slower; the comparison is similar to the mace, but more extreme.
 +
 
 +
Another potential use is for [[ideoligion]]{{IdeologyIcon}} with the Melee Blunt set as Noble weapons, providing a sharp-type weapon option that grants mood buffs instead of penalties.
 +
 
 +
{{Weapon Quality Table}}
  
 
== Styles ==
 
== Styles ==

Please note that all contributions to RimWorld Wiki are considered to be released under the CC BY-SA 3.0 (see RimWorld Wiki:Copyrights for details). If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly and redistributed at will, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource. Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)

Templates used on this page:

This page is a member of 1 hidden category:

Retrieved from "https://rimworldwiki.com/wiki/Axe"